Hi,
Ah ok. So it's a one time extra fee.
In that case, I would recommend using this plugin:
www.hikashop.com/marketplace/product/279-cart-fee.html
You could use a formula like this:
and it would add a $1 fee to each cart.
And if you don't want the fee to be charged twice, you could configure an order mass action (menu System>Mass actions) to move the users from the "registered" user group to another user group "members" after each purchase.
And then, you could use the access level setting of the cart fees plugin so that it is loaded only for guest users and users in the group "registered" so that when users from the "members" user group are checking out, this plugin is not loaded and the fee is not added to the cart.