joshualdouglas wrote: I have duplicated this cart module and now I have 2
Nope, you now have no less than 4 cart modules. Both 471 and 841 in each of the two positions.
Looks like either a module positioning issue in the Joomla Module Manager (unlikely)... or (rather likely) caused by the Joomla template and its module position structure or page builder or something. If you can't get it fixed yourself, it may be worth to check with the template/framework makers (Joomshaper) on how you're supposed to have such two modules placed in the menu header so that they both are in the HTML only once each, with one showing only on smaller screens and the other only on larger ones.